Episode 59 - Collect First, Justify Later

Podcast Show Notes
1

Show Notes -

Website / Donations / Support - Support

BTC Lightning Donations - [email protected] / [email protected]

Thank You Patreons & Direct Supporters! -
https://www.patreon.com/closednetwork

Direct Support - https://closednetwork.io

Subscribe Without Patreon - Closed Network Privacy Podcast

  • Michael Bates - Privacy Bad Ass
  • David - Privacy Bad Ass
  • TK - Privacy Bad Ass
  • Trying - Privacy Bad Ass
  • VO - Privacy Bad Ass
  • MrMilkMustache - Privacy Supporter
  • Hutch - Privacy Advocate
  • Inferno_Potato Privacy Supporter
  • Dolores Y - Privacy Supporter

Direct Support - Craig D

Thank You Producers! You Produce This Show!

TOP LIGHTNING BOOSTERS !!! THANK YOU !!!

  • @bon thousands and thousands and thousands of SATs sats!!
  • @fireflygow - 5,000 sats!!
  • frigolay - 34,540 SATs… HOLY SHITE
  • wardemoff - 5,000 SATs
  • Silas Thornbrook

XMR CHAT BOOSTS

- HookersOnPhonics - $20

Thank You To Our Moderators:

Unintelligentseven - Follow on NOSTR primal.net/p/npub15rp9gyw346fmcxgdlgp2y9a2xua9ujdk9nzumflshkwjsc7wepwqnh354d
MaddestMax - Follow on NOSTR primal.net/p/npub133yzwsqfgvsuxd4clvkgupshzhjn52v837dlud6gjk4tu2c7grqq3sxavt

Join Our Community

Closed Network Forum - https://forum.closednetwork.io

Join Our Matrix Channels!
Main - https://matrix.to/#/#closedntwrk:matrix.org
Off Topic - https://matrix.to/#/#closednetworkofftopic:matrix.org
SimpleX Group Chat - SimpleX Chat - Invitation

Join Our Mastodon server!

Follow Simon On The Socials

Mastodon - Simon :verified: (@[email protected]) - Closed Network Social
NOSTR - Public Address - npub186l3994gark0fhknh9zp27q38wv3uy042appcpx93cack5q2n03qte2lu2 - primal.net/simon
Twitter / X - @ClosedNtwrk

Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/closednetworkpodcast/

YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@closednetwork
Email - [email protected]

Special Thanks to - EloquentWinter for creating - A Linux guide on MAC address randomization

TOPICS

IN THIS EPISODE

01

The Man Who Built FISA — And Watched It Break

The FBI lawyer who designed the bureau’s FISA safeguards says that after he left in 2006 they were dismantled — and the system ballooned into Section 702.

02

EU Chat Control: The Majority Said No. The Scan Survived.

A parliamentary majority voted against message scanning on 9 July — and it survived anyway on a second-reading technicality, now running to 2028.

03

SCOTUS, Flock & the Cameras That Don’t Care.

The Supreme Court ruled that reconstructing your movements is a ‘search’ — but 113,000+ license-plate cameras keep rolling, and the fix isn’t in a courtroom.

04

Your Face Is a Password You Can’t Change.

Madison Square Garden’s facial-recognition system leaked — watchlists included — after a single phishing call. Why every face database is a breach-in-waiting.

05

Tools to Own the Stack.

Three open-source projects worth your time — one per fight: DeFlock, SimpleX Chat, and GrapheneOS.

Timestamps are estimates based on segment order — update after the final edit.

00:00Cold Open & Episode Rundown

02:00The Man Who Built FISA

08:30EU Chat Control Update

14:30SCOTUS, Flock & the Cameras

20:00Your Face Is a Password You Can’t Change

25:00Tools to Own the Stack

28:00Outro

SEGMENT TAKEAWAYS

The Man Who Built FISA

  • FISA (1978) was sold as a reform, but it legitimized surveillance the government had previously run with no statute at all.
  • The FISA court rarely says no because the real filtering was designed to happen upstream, inside the FBI.
  • Bowman built that pipeline — embedded lawyers, months of review, personal sign-off. After he left in 2006, it went passive.
  • The Carter Page applications (17+ errors; a doctored email; a guilty plea) showed the cost.
  • 2008’s Amendments Act created Section 702 — blanket categories, no named targets, a queryable database of Americans’ data.
  • Thesis: the danger isn’t who builds a surveillance system — it’s everyone who inherits it.

EU Chat Control

  • Two proposals, one name: 1.0 (temporary, voluntary) vs. 2.0 / CSAR (permanent, mandatory).
  • 26 Mar 2026: Parliament rejected the temporary rules 307–306; the derogation expired 3 April.
  • 9 Jul 2026: more MEPs voted to kill the revived scheme than keep it (reported 314–276), but rejecting the Council needed 361 votes. It survived — extended to 3 April 2028, with an E2E carve-out.
  • The permanent CSAR could be adopted as soon as October 2026.
  • Client-side scanning is the core danger; 500+ scientists call it infeasible; Signal would exit the EU. Watch Germany.

SCOTUS, Flock & the Cameras

  • Chatrie v. United States (29 Jun 2026, 6–3): a geofence is a ‘search’; police generally need a warrant. Built on Carpenter (2018).
  • The Court didn’t ban geofence warrants and never mentioned ALPRs — a principle above a system it doesn’t touch.
  • Scale: 113,000+ cameras; ~20B detections/month across ~5,000 departments vs. ~240M drivers.
  • A 2 Jul 2026 ACLU report documented Flock misleading councils (the Oshkosh ‘heat map’ reversal).
  • At least 82 jurisdictions have canceled ALPR contracts. The durable fix is local — stop collection.

Your Face Is a Password You Can’t Change

  • MSG breached by ShinyHunters via a phishing call; ~45GB / ~26M claimed records, including facial-recognition records and threat profiles.
  • MSG used facial recognition for years — including to bar opposing lawyers. Second breach in under a year; class actions filed.
  • A pattern, not an accident: Clearview’s client list leaked in 2020; Mercor exposed biometrics + ID docs in April 2026.
  • Biometrics are irreversible — you can’t reissue your face. The safeguard is not building the database.

TOOLS MENTIONED

Open source · not sponsored · no affiliate relationships.

DeFlock · pairs with the Flock segment

Crowdsourced ALPR camera map on OpenStreetMap; has mapped ~half of Flock’s ~100,000-camera network so you can see and route around them.

SimpleX Chat · pairs with Chat Control

Messenger with no user identifiers at all — the metadata-resistance layer E2E encryption alone doesn’t give you. Audited by Trail of Bits.

simplex.chat

GrapheneOS · pairs with every segment

Hardened, de-Googled Android on Pixel — the endpoint is where client-side scanning and biometric capture actually land.

SOURCES & REFERENCES

Segment 1 — FISA

Segment 2 — EU Chat Control

Segment 3 — SCOTUS / Flock

Segment 4 — Facial Recognition / Breaches

Segment 5 — Tools